Mr. Ohio All-Star Titleholders
Pappi Mitchell
Rob Dennick
Gavyn Sanchez
Phoenix Storm
Skyler Styles
Lucky
Rob Austin
Joey Fleming
Octavius Rashad
Izaya Cole
Kevin Carlson
Shampaine Austen Lee
Geo Vaughn Cole
Redd Valentine – Photo by Bryce McCaughey
Prince Cole
Mr. Ohio All-Star Titleholders
- 2000 – Pappi Mitchell
- 2001 – Rob Dennick
- 2002 – Gavyn Sanchez
- 2004 – Phoenix Storm
- 2005 – Skyler Styles
- 2006 – Lucky
- 2007 – Rob Austin
- 2008 – Joey Fleming
- 2010 – Octavius Rashad
- 2012 – Izaya Cole
- 2013 – Kevin Carlson
- 2014 – Shampaine Austen Lee
- 2016 – Geo Vaughn Cole
- 2017 – Redd Valentine
- 2018 – Prince Cole
Prelims to Mr. Ohio All-Star
Mr. Ohio All-Star History
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2018
- Winner – Prince Cole
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2017
- Winner – Redd Valentine
- 1st Alternate –
- 2nd Alternate –
- 3rd Alternate – Adonis Casanova
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2016
- Winner – Geo Vaughn Cole
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2015
Pageant not held.
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2014
- Winner – Shampaine Austen Lee
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2013
- Winner – Kevin Carlson
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2012
- Winner – Izaya Cole
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2011
- Winner – ???
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2010
- Winner – Octavius Rashad
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2009
Pageant not held.
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2008
- Winner – Joey Fleming
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2007
- Winner – Rob Austin
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2006
- Winner – Lucky
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2005
- Winner – Skyler Styles
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2004
- Winner – Phoenix Storm
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2003
Pageant not held.
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2002
- Winner – Gavyn Sanchez
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2001
- Winner – Rob Dennick
Mr. Ohio All-Star 2000
- Winner – Pappi Mitchell