From 1985 through 2009 this pageant was known as Mr. Gay USA. The system, originally started by Jerry Bird, was sold to Jeff Reeves aka Nancy Newton and later in 2010 it became known as Mr. USA Unlimited. All of the previous Mr. Gay USA winners are recognized within the system. The system dissolved in 2017.
Mr. USA Unlimited Titleholders
Mark Ambrosey 
Chuck Roberson 
Kevin Scott 
Jody Hanvey 
Kimball Puckerson 
Todd Wentz 
Tony DiAngelo 
Chachi 
Jeff Reeves 
John Wayne Wilson 
D’Andre 
Douglas Bayne 
Kristian Martinez – Photo by Tios Photography 
Tyler Thomas 
John Michael Gordon 
Antonio Edwards 
Kyle Ean 
Raphael Matthews 
Monte Ross St. James 
Ray Matthews 
Joey Rivera 
Eric Rainbow 
Neo Hall Richards 
Izaya Cole 
Cielo Whitney – Photo by Estevan Serena 
Mykel Knight-Addams Iman St. James 
Judas Elliot – Photo by Erika Wagner Artistry 
Taylor Knight Addams St. James 
Devon Iman Dickerson Diamond – Photo by Kristofer Reynolds 
Xavier Diamond – Photo by After Six Photography
Mr. USA Unlimited Titleholders
- 1985 – Mark Ambrosey
- 1986 – Chuck Roberson
- 1987 – Kevin Scott
- 1988 – Jody Hanvey
- 1989 – Kimball Puckerson
- 1990 – Todd Wentz
- 1991 – Tony DiAngelo
- 1992 – Chachi
- 1993 – Jeff Reeves
- 1994 – John Wayne Wilson
- 1995 – D’Andre
- 1996 – Douglas Bayne
- 1997 – Kristian Martinez
- 1998 – Tyler Thomas
- 1999 – John Michael Gordan
- 2000 – Stephen Michael
- 2001 – Antonio Edwards
- 2002 – Kyle Ean
- 2003 – Raphael Matthews
- 2004 – Ryan Davis
- 2005 – Monte St. James
- 2006 – Ray Matthews
- 2007 – Joey Rivera
- 2008 – Eric Rainbow
- 2009 – Neo Hall Richards
- 2010 – Izaya Cole
- 2011 – Cielo Whitney
- 2012 – Mykel Knight-Addams Iman
- 2013 – Judas Elliot
- 2014 – Taylor Knight Addams
- 2015 – Devon Iman Dickerson Diamond
- 2016 – Xavier Diamond
Prelims to Mr. USA Unlimited
- Mr. South Carolina USA Unlimited
- Mr. Texas USA Unlimited
- Mr. West Virginia USA Unlimited
- Mr. Wisconsin USA Unlimited
Mr. USA Unlimited History
Mr. USA Unlimited 2016
- Winner – Xavier Diamond
Mr. USA Unlimited 2015
- Winner – Devon Iman Dickerson Diamond
Mr. USA Unlimited 2014
- Winner – Taylor Knight Addams
Mr. USA Unlimited 2013
- Winner – Judas Elliot
- 1st Alternate – Mirage Cruz Matthews
Mr. USA Unlimited 2012
- Winner – Mykel Knight-Addams Iman
Mr. USA Unlimited 2011
- Winner – Cielo Whitney
Mr. USA Unlimited 2010
- Winner – Izaya Cole
Mr. Gay USA History
Mr. Gay USA 2009
- Winner – Neo Hall Richards
Mr. Gay USA 2008
- Winner – Eric Rainbow
Mr. Gay USA 2007
- Winner – Joey Rivera
Mr. Gay USA 2006
- Winner – Ray Matthews
Mr. Gay USA 2005
- Winner – Monte St. James
Mr. Gay USA 2004
- Winner – Ryan Davis
Mr. Gay USA 2003
- Winner – Raphael Matthews
Mr. Gay USA 2002
- Winner – Kyle Ean
Mr. Gay USA 2001
- Winner – Antonio Edwards
Mr. Gay USA 2000
- Winner – Stephen Michael
Mr. Gay USA 1999
- Winner – John Michael Gordan
Mr. Gay USA 1998
- Winner – Tyler Thomas
Mr. Gay USA 1997
- Winner – Kristian Martinez
Mr. Gay USA 1996
- Winner – Douglas Bayne
Mr. Gay USA 1995
- Winner – D’Andre
Mr. Gay USA 1994
- Winner – John Wayne Wilson
Mr. Gay USA 1993
- Winner – Jeff Reeves
Mr. Gay USA 1992
- Winner – Cha-Chi
Mr. Gay USA 1991
- Winner – Tony DiAngelo
Mr. Gay USA 1990
- Winner – Todd Wentz
Mr. Gay USA 1989
- Winner – Kimball Puckerson
Mr. Gay USA 1988
- Winner – Jody Hanvey
Mr. Gay USA 1987
- Winner – Kevin Scott
Mr. Gay USA 1986
- Winner – Chuck Roberson
Mr. Gay USA 1985
- Winner – Mark Ambrosey