Miss Sweetheart International Plus Titleholders
Alexis Gabrielle Sherrington 
Dorae Saunders 
Tamara Chevalier 
Tahjee Iman 
Ivy White 
Victoria LePaige 
Valencia Santiago 
Nina Cherry 
Angelica Sanchez 
Desiree DeMornay 
Terri Williams 
Erica Martinez 
Kitti Katwell 
Katrina Davenport-Dupree 
Monica Dupree – Photo by Tios Photography 
Nala Couture Alexandria 
Malaysia Kenyatta Black 
Pretti St. James-Golden 
Christian Valentino
Miss Sweetheart International Plus Titleholders
Miss Sweetheart International Plus Titleholders
- 1995 – Alexis Gabrielle Sherrington
- 1997 – Dorae Saunders
- 1998 – Tamara Chevalier
- 1999 – Tahjee Iman
- 2000 – Ivy White ***
- 2002 – Victoria LePaige
- 2004 – Valencia Santiago
- 2005 – Nina Cherry
- 2006 – Angelica Sanchez
- 2007 – Desiree DeMornay
- 2008 – Terri Williams
- 2009 – Erica Martinez
- 2010 – Kitti Katwell
- 2011 – Katrina Davenport-Dupree
- 2012 – Monica Dupree
- 2013 – Nala Couture Alexandria
- 2015 – Malaysia Kenyatta Black
- 2016 – Pretti St. James-Golden
- 2018 – Christian Valentino
*** In Loving Memory