Miss Gay New York America is a prelim to Miss Gay America.

Miss Gay New York America Titleholders

• 2017 – Kelly Ray Shelton

Miss Gay New York America History

Miss Gay New York America 2018

• Winner –

Show Ad | Miss Gay New York America | Hudson Terrace (New York City, New York) | 3/13/2018

Miss Gay New York America 2017

• Winner – Kelly Ray Shelton
• 1st Alternate – Champagne Bubbles