Miss Gay New York America is a prelim to Miss Gay America.
Miss Gay New York America Titleholders
Kelly Ray 
Andora Te’Tee 
Truly Fabu
Miss Gay New York America Titleholders
- 2017 – Kelly Ray Shelton
- 2018 – Andora Tetee
- 2019 – Truly Fabu
Miss Gay New York America History
- 2017
- Winner – Kelly Ray Shelton
- 1st Alternate – Champagne Bubbles
- Photo Archive: 7/24/2017 – Hudson Terrace (New York, New York) – Miss Gay New York America
- 2018
- Winner – Andora Tetee
- 1st Alternate – Dessie Love Blake
- Photo Archive: 3/12-3/13/2018 – Hudson Terrace (New York, New York) – Miss Gay New York America and Mr. Gay New York America
- 2019
- Winner – Truly Fabu
- 1st Alternate – Pattaya Hart