Miss Gay City Lights America is a prelim to Miss Gay Ohio America.
Miss Gay City Lights America Titleholders
Lisa Cartier 
Alexis O’Hara 
Ariel DuVois 
Symphony Alexander-Love 
Cece Devine 
Mercedes Denishayae Marie Taylor 
Cierra Nicole 
Nea Bottoms 
Erika Larae 
Veronica Deveraux 
Rushena Fontaine 
Elegance Black Lourdes 
Honey Below 
Mya Motions
Miss Gay City Lights America Titleholders
- 1999 – Lisa Cartier
- 2000 – Alexis O’Hara
- 2002 – Ariel DuVois
- 2003 – Symphony Alexander-Love
- 2006 – Cece Devine
- 2006/2007 – Mercedes Marie Taylor
- 2007 – Cierra Nicole
- 2008 – Nea Bottoms
- 2009 – Erika Larae
- 2010 – Veronica Devereaux
- 2011 – Rushena Fontaine
- 2012 – Elegance Black Lourdes
- 2013 – Honey Below
- 2021 – Mya Motions
Miss Gay City Lights America History
- Miss Gay City Lights America 1999
- Winner – Lisa Cartier
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2000
- Winner – Alexis O’Hara
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2001
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2002
- Winner – Ariel DuVois
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2003
- Winner – Symphony Alexander-Love
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2004 – 2005
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2006
- Winner – Cece Devine
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2006/2007
- Winner – Mercedes Marie Taylor
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2007
- Winner – Cierra Nicole
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2008
- Winner – Nea Bottoms
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2009
- Winner – Erika Larae
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2010
- Winner – Veronica Devereaux
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2011
- Winner – Rushena Fontaine
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2012
- Winner – Elegance Black Lourdes
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2013
- Winner – Honey Below
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2014 – 2020
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay City Lights America 2021
- Winner – Anita Snatch
- 1st Alternate – Mya Motions
- Note: Anita Snatch was unable to attend the state pageant due to a family emergency so the title and crown was passed on to Mya Motions.
- Location: Southbend Tavern (Columbus, Ohio)
- Date: 7/25/2021
- Photo Archive: Miss Gay City Lights America | Southbend Tavern (Columbus, Ohio) | 7/25/2021
- Categories and Awards:
- Male Interview: Mya Motions
- Evening Gown: Mya Motions
- On Stage Question: Mya Motions
- Talent: Anita Snatch
