Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer is a prelim to Miss Gay USofA Newcomer.
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer Titleholders
Vanessa Ryan 
LaLa DeMornay 
Jaymee Sexton – Photo by J. Bowen Photography 
Misty Terrain
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer Titleholders
- 2010 – Vanessa Ryan
- 2013 – LaLa DeMornay
- 2016 – Jaymee Sexton
- 2022 – Misty Terrain
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer History
| Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2022 |
|---|
| Winner – Misty Terrain 1st Alternate – Serenity Grace-Brooks |
| Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2017 – 2021 |
|---|
| Needs researched. |
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2016
- Winner – Jaymee Sexton
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2014 – 2015
Pageant status unknown.
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2013
- Winner – LaLa DeMornay
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2011 – 2012
Pageant status unknown.
Miss Gay Midwest USofA Newcomer 2010
- Winner – Vanessa Ryan
