Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer is a prelim to Miss Gay USofA Newcomer.
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer Titleholders
Vanessa Ryan 
Ryan Royale – Photo by Jose Hernandez Photography 
Eva Alicia Jane 
Madison Blackwell 
Karina Phoenix – Photo by Laura Dark Photography
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer Titleholders
- 2011 – Vanessa Ryan
- 2016 – Ryan Royale
- 2017 – Eva Alicia Jane
- 2018 – Madison Blackwell
- 2019 – Karina Phoenix
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer History
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2019
- Winner – Karina Phoenix
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2018
- Winner – Madison Blackwell
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2017
- Winner – Eva Alicia Jane
- 1st Alternate – Coco Deville
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2016
- Winner – Ryan Royale
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2012 – 2015
Needs researched.
Miss Gay Indiana USofA Newcomer 2011
- Winner – Vanessa Ryan
