Prior to 2010 this pageant was known as Mr. Gay USA FMI. In 2010 it became known as Mr. USA Unlimited FMI. All of the previous Mr. Gay USA FMI winners are recognized within the system. The division official closed in 2020.
Mr. Gay USA FMI / Mr. USA Unlimited FMI Titleholders
Mr. Gay USA FMI Titleholders
- 1996 – 1997 – Nicholas Andrews
- 2001 – 2002 – Zackery Roberts
- 2004 – Chase Thompson
- 2005 – Romance St. James
- 2006 – Gage Gatlyn
- 2007 – DRoc
- 2008 – JR Stallings
- 2009 – Colten Haze
Mr. USA Unlimited FMI Titleholders
- 2010 – Country Casinova ***
- 2011 – Maccon Haze
- 2012 – Nation Tyre
- 2013 – Cory Stone
- 2014 – Shook ByNature
- 2015 – Viktor Grimm
- 2016 – Teddy Michael
*** In Loving Memory
Prelims to Mr. USA Unlimited FMI
