Mr. Gay New York America is a prelim to Mr. Gay America.
Mr. Gay New York America Titleholders
Quinn Matthews 
Geo Glam – Photo by Tios Photography
Mr. Gay New York America Titleholders
- 2018 – Quinn Matthews
- 2020 – Geo Glam
Mr. Gay New York America History
| Mr. Gay New York America 2020 |
|---|
| Winner – Geo Glam 1st Alternate – Jovan Cardin IV |
| ARCHIVE: Mr. and Miss Gay New York America | Cutting Room (New York, New York) | 3/10/2020 |
| Mr. Gay New York America 2019 |
|---|
| Needs researched. |
| Mr. Gay New York America 2018 |
|---|
| Winner – Quinn Matthews |
| ARCHIVE: Mr. and Miss Gay New York America | Hudson Terrace (New York, New York) | 3/12-3/13/2018 |
