Mr. Columbus All-Star is a prelim to Mr. Ohio All-Star.
Mr. Columbus All-Star Titleholders
Lucky Blake Walker Black Starr Andy Rogeny Jake Michaels Decardeza – Photo by Foto Images by Ken
Mr. Columbus All-Star Titleholders
- 2005 – Lucky
- 2010 – Blake Walker ***
- 2014 – Black Starr
- 2017 – Andy Rogeny
- 2018 – Jake Michaels Decardeza
***In Loving Memory