Miss Gay Arizona America is a prelim to Miss Gay America.
Miss Gay Arizona America Titleholders
Tamara 
Jamie DeSario 
Penelope Poupe 
Mona Littlemore 
Devina Ross 
Amanda McLamara 
Pussy LeHoot 
Kyra Starr 
Lucinda Holliday 
Ms. Marcus 
Gilda Fatale 
Virginia Sacrifice 
Kenneth Blake 
Barbra Seville 
Phaedra 
Angela Dodd 
Chane Jordan 
Bunny Fu Fu 
Tori Steele 
Amanda Bury 
Mikaila Kay 
Mya McKenzie 
Sache Van Cartier 
TC Taylor 
Celebrity Starr 
Celia Putty 
Diva – Photo by Diane Graham Photography 
Tyra Marie 
Grecia Montes D’Occa 
Nevaeh McKenzie – Photo by Scotty Kirby 
Savannah Stevens – Photo by Scotty Kirby 
Olivia Gardens 
Adriana Galliano – Photo by Scotty Kirby 
Espressa Grande – Photo by Scotty Kirby 
Sicarya Seville – Photo by Scotty Kirby
Miss Gay Arizona America Titleholders
- 1986 – Tamara
- 1987 – Jamie DeSario
- 1988 – Penelope Poupe ***
- 1989 – Mona Littlemore
- 1990 – Devina Ross
- 1991 – Amanda McLamara
- 1992 – Pussy LeHoot
- 1993 – Kyra Starr
- 1994 – Lucinda Holliday
- 1995 – Ms. Marcus ***
- 1996 – Gilda Fatale
- 1997 – Virginia Sacrifice
- 1998 – Kenneth Blake
- 2000 – Barbra Seville
- 2001 – Phaedra
- 2002 – Angela Dodd
- 2003 – Chane Jordan
- 2004 – Bunny Fu Fu
- 2005 – Tori Steele
- 2006 – Amanda Bury
- 2006/2007 – Mikaila Kay
- 2007 – Mya McKenzie
- 2008 – Sache Van Cartier ***
- 2009 – TC Taylor
- 2010 – Celebrity Starr
- 2011 – Celia Putty
- 2012 – Diva
- 2013 – Tyra Marie
- 2014 – Grecia Montes D’Occa
- 2015 – Nevaeh McKenzie
- 2016 – Savannah Stevens
- 2017 – Olivia Gardens
- 2018 – Adriana Galliano
- 2019 – 2020 – Espressa Grande
- 2021 – Sicarya Seville
***In Loving Memory
Prelims to Miss Gary Arizona America:
- Copper City America
- Cosmopolitan America
- Phoenix America
- Queen of the Desert America
- Scottsdale America
- Tucson America
Miss Gay Arizona America History
| Miss Gay Arizona America 2021 |
|---|
| Winner – Sicarya Seville 1st Alternate – Claudia B 2nd Alternate – Patricia Mason 3rd Alternate – Franzia McKenzie 4th Alternate – Mynx DeMilo |
| ARCHIVE: Miss Gay Arizona America | AURA (Tempe, Arizona) | 8/7/2021 |
| Miss Gay Arizona America 2020 |
|---|
| No pageant held due to Covid-19 pandemic. |
Miss Gay Arizona America 2019
- Winner – Espressa Grande
- 1st Alternate – Sicarya
Miss Gay Arizona America 2018
- Winner – Adriana Galliano
- 1st Alternate – Claudia B
Miss Gay Arizona America 2017
- Winner – Olivia Gardens
- 1st Alternate – Piper M’Shay
Miss Gay Arizona America 2016
- Winner – Savannah Stevens
- 1st Alternate – Bianca Solei
Miss Gay Arizona America 2015
- Winner – Nevaeh McKenzie
- 1st Alternate – Savannah Stevens
Miss Gay Arizona America 2014
- Winner – Grecia Montes D’Occa
- 1st Alternate – Savannah Stevens
Miss Gay Arizona America 2013
- Winner – Tyra Marie
- 1st Alternate – Savannah Stevens
- 2nd Alternate – Oliva Gardens
- 3rd Alternate – Jimena Cavali
- 4th Alternate – Lady Christian
Miss Gay Arizona America 2012
- Winner – Diva
- 1st Alternate – Oliva Gardens
Miss Gay Arizona America 2011
- Winner – Celia Putty
- 1st Alternate – Tyra Marie
Miss Gay Arizona America 2010
- Winner – Celebrity Starr
- 1st Alternate – Tyra Marie
Miss Gay Arizona America 2009
- Winner – TC Taylor
- 1st Alternate – Celebrity Starr
Miss Gay Arizona America 2008
- Winner – Sache Van Cartier
Miss Gay Arizona America 2007
- Winner – Mya McKenzie
- 1st Alternate – Jessica Deveraux
Miss Gay Arizona America 2006/2007
- Winner – Mikaila Kay
- 1st Alternate – Mya McKenzie
Miss Gay Arizona America 2006
- Winner – Amanda Bury
- 1st Alternate – Heather Boa
Miss Gay Arizona America 2005
- Winner – Tori Steele
- 1st Alternate – Janee Starr
Miss Gay Arizona America 2004
- Winner – Bunny Fu Fu
- 1st Alternate – Veronica Halliwell
Miss Gay Arizona America 2003
- Winner – Chane Jordan
- 1st Alternate – Aurora Gayheart
Miss Gay Arizona America 2002
- Winner – Angela Dodd
- 1st Alternate – Chane Jordan
Miss Gay Arizona America 2001
- Winner – Phaedra
- 1st Alternate – Angela Dodd
Miss Gay Arizona America 2000
- Winner – Barbra Seville
- 1st Alternate – Phaedra
Miss Gay Arizona America 1999
This year needs additional research.
Miss Gay Arizona America 1998
- Winner – Kenneth Blake
- 1st Alternate – Phaedra
Miss Gay Arizona America 1997
- Winner – Virginia Sacrifice
- 1st Alternate – Barbra Seville
Miss Gay Arizona America 1996
- Winner – Gilda Fatale
Miss Gay Arizona America 1995
- Winner – Ms. Marcus
Miss Gay Arizona America 1994
- Winner – Lucinda Holliday
Miss Gay Arizona America 1993
- Winner – Kyra Starr
Miss Gay Arizona America 1992
- Winner – Pussy LeHoot
Miss Gay Arizona America 1991
- Winner – Amanda McLamara
Miss Gay Arizona America 1990
- Winner – Devina Ross
Miss Gay Arizona America 1989
- Winner – Mona Littlemore
Miss Gay Arizona America 1988
- Winner – Penelope Poupe
Miss Gay Arizona America 1987
- Winner – Jamie DeSario
Miss Gay Arizona America 1986
- Winner – Tamara
