The Miss Toledo Gay Pride pageant is a prelim to the Miss Ohio Gay Pride pageant.
Miss Toledo Gay Pride Titleholders
Rya Chiffon 
Hershae Chocolatae 
Brionna Brooks 
Deja D. Dellataro 
Symphony Alexander-Love 
Isis Fontaine 
Amber Stone 
April Evangelista 
MaKayla Styles 
Cherry Poppins 
Reianna Ali 
Chanel Hunter 
Porcelain Knights 
Saphyre Rayhne – Photo by Bryce McCaughey Photography 
Kimora Lee Davenport
Miss Toledo Gay Pride Titleholders
- 2004 – Rya Chiffon
- 2005 – Hershae Chocolatae
- 2006 – Brionna Brooks
- 2007 – Deja Dellataro
- 2008 – Symphony Alexander-Love
- 2009 – Isis Fontaine
- 2010 – Amber Stone
- 2011 – April Evangelista
- 2012 – MaKayla Styles
- 2013 – Cherry Poppins
- 2014 – Reianna Ali
- 2015 – Chanel Hunter
- 2016 – Porcelain Knights
- 2018 – Saphyre Rayhne
- 2019 – Kimora Lee Davenport
Miss Toledo Gay Pride History
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2019
- Winner – Kimora Lee Davenport
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2018
- Winner – Saphyre Rayhne
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2017
- Winner – Ember Holiday Monroe
- 1st Alternate – Princess Kiki
Neither the winner or 1st alternate went to state competition so no one is honored from this year.
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2016
- Winner – Porcelain Knights
- 1st Alternate – Leyomie Leshae Asia
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2015
- Winner – Chanel Hunter
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2014
- Winner – Reianna Ali
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2013
- Winner – Cherry Poppins
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2012
- Winner – MaKayla Styles
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2011
- Winner – April Evangelista
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2010
- Winner – Amber Stone
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2009
- Winner – Isis Fontaine
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2008
- Winner – Symphony Alexander-Love
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2007
- Winner – Deja Dellataro
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2006
- Winner – Brionna Brooks
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2005
- Winner – Hershae Chocolatae
Miss Toledo Gay Pride 2004
- Winner – Rya Chiffon
