Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America is a prelim to Miss Gay North Carolina America.
Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America Titleholders
Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America Titleholders
- 2015 – Kimora Lee Matthews
- 2016 – Paris Brooks-Bonet
Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America History
Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America 2016
- Winner – Paris Brooks-Bonet
- 1st Alternate – Kristiana Elite
Miss Gay Carolina Sugar America 2015
- Winner – Kimora Lee Matthews
