Miss Gay Cleveland America is a prelim to Miss Gay Ohio America.
Miss Gay Cleveland America Titleholders
Miss Gay Cleveland America Titleholders
- 1993 – Erica Martinez
- 1994 – Chante Seville ***
- 1995 – Cher Andrea
- 1996 – Nicole Andrews
- 1997 – Andria Michaels
- 1998 – Lisa Cartier
- 1999 – Shasta Reed
- 2000 – Linda Lacee
- 2004 – Krystal Stone ***
- 2005 – Pandora Boxx ***
- 2006 – Satin Rose ***
- 2006/2007 – Akasha O’Hara Lords
- 2007 – Natalie Santana
- 2008 – Carla Visconte
- 2014 – Brandee Van Moore
- 2017 – Valerie Valentino
- 2018 – Mystical Divine
- 2019 – Angelica Arkett
- 2021 – Evona Valentino St. James
- 2022 – Sasha F. Mizrahe
*** In Loving Memory
A photo is needed for Shasta Reed.
Miss Gay Cleveland America History
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1993
- Winner – Erica Martinez
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1994
- Winner – Chante Seville
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1995
- Winner – Cher Andrea
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1996
- Winner – Nicole Andrews
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1997
- Winner – Andria Michaels
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1998
- Winner – Lisa Cartier
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 1999
- Winner – Shasta Reed
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2000
- Winner – Linda Lacee
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2001 – 2003
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2004
- Winner – Krystal Stone
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2005
- Winner – Pandora Boxx
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2006
- Winner – Satin Rose
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2006/2007
- Winner – Akasha O’Hara Lords
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2007
- Winner – Natalie Santana
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2008
- Winner – Carla Visconte
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2009 – 2013
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2014
- Winner – Brandee Van Moore
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2015 – 2016
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2017
- Winner – Valerie Valentino
- 1st Alternate – Alexis Milan
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2018
- Winner – Mystical Divine
- 1st Alternate – Sasha F. Mizrahe
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2019
- Winner – Angelica Arkett
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2020
- No pageant held due to Covid-19 pandemic.
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2021
- Winner – Evona Valentino James
- 1st Alternate – Alexis Milan
- Miss Gay Cleveland America 2022
