Mr. Gay Ohio America is a prelim to Mr. Gay America. Prior to 2017, the contest was known as Mr. Gay Ohio All-American.
Mr. Gay Ohio America Titleholders
James Randall 
Simba R. Hall – Photo by Tios Photography 
Tyler Hall – Photo by Tios Photography
Mr. Gay Ohio America Titleholders
- 1998 – James Randall
- 2018 – Simba Hall
- 2021 – Tyler Hall
Mr. Gay Ohio America History
- Mr. Gay Ohio All-America 1998
- Winner –
- Mr. Gay Ohio America 2018
- Winner – Simba Hall
- 1st Alternate – Vincent Debeauté
- 2nd Alternate – Izaya Cole
Show Ad | Boscoe’s (Columbus, Ohio) | 5/19/2018 
Show Ad | Mr. Gay Ohio America | Axis Night Club (Columbus, Ohio) | 5/20/2018
*Coti Collins was in show ad for Review Show but was unable to attend due competing in Miss Gay USofA Classic.
- Mr. Gay Ohio America 2021
- Winner – Tyler Hall
- 1st Alternate – Isaac Ismael
