Miss Black America Plus Titleholders
Fabian Sanchez 
Tanisha Iman – Photo by Tios Photography 
Amanda Elizabeth Korday 
Zakia Jamaceye 
Tamara Chevalier 
Kelexis Davenport 
Ava Chanel Alexandria 
Summer Knight 
Lady Deception – Photo by Kristofer Reynolds 
Armani Nicole Davenport 
India Damore 
Debutaunt McCray 
Nina Cherry – Photo by Kristofer Reynolds 
Monica Dupree – Photo by Tios Photography 
Ivy White 
Christian Valentino 
Pebbles – Photo by Tios Photography
Miss Black America Plus Titleholders
- 1995 – Fabian Sanchez
- 1996 – Tanisha Iman
- 1998 – Amanda Elizabeth Korday
- 1999 – Zakia Jemaceye
- 2000 – Tamara Chevalier
- 2001 – Kelexis Davenport
- 2002 – Ava Chanel Alexandria
- 2004 – Summer Knight
- 2005 – Lady Deception
- 2006 – Armani Nicole Davenport
- 2007 – India Damore
- 2008 – Debutaunt McCray
- 2009 – Nina Cherry
- 2010 – Monica Dupree
- 2013 – Ivy White ***
- 2014 – Christian Valentino
- 2016 – Pebbles
*** In Loving Memory
