Miss Gay Indianapolis became a direct prelim to Miss Gay Indiana in 2008. Prior to this, it was a city pageant and was a prelim to Miss Gay Indiana America through 2005 when the state pageant separated itself from the Miss Gay America organization.
Miss Gay Indianapolis America / Miss Gay Indiana Titleholders
Blake Adams 
Jasmine Summers 
Jamie Hunter 
June Taylor 
Jazmyn Taylor 
Fontasia L’Amour 
Stacy Stevens 
Vanity Gibson Stamos 
Asia LaBouche 
Tonya Bear Rogers 
Amanda Nicole 
India Black 
Annastacia DeMoore 
Holly Luyah 
Erica King 
Courtney Anderson 
Regina Bitch 
Pat Yo Weave 
Alana Steele 
Halle Pino 
Samantha Lynn
Miss Gay Indianapolis America Titleholders
- 1990 – Blake Adams
- 1991 – Jasmine Summers
- 1992 – Jamie Hunter
- 1993 – June Taylor
- 1994 – Ashley Brooks ***
- 1995 – Jazmyn Taylor
- 1996 – Fontasia L’Amour
- 1997 – Stacy Stevens
- 1998 – Vanity Gibson Stamos
- 1999 – Misti McCrea
- 2000 – Tandy Ross
- 2001 – Asia LaBouche
- 2002 – Tonya Bear Rogers
- 2003 – Amanda Nicole ***
- 2004 – India Black
- 2005 – Annastacia DeMoore
*** In Loving Memory
Miss Gay Indianapolis Titleholders
- 2007 – Holly Luyah
- 2008 – Erica King
- 2009 – Courtney Anderson
- 2010 – Regina Bitch
- 2012 – Pat Yo Weave
- 2013 – Alana Steele
- 2014 – Halle Pino
- 2020 – Samantha Lynn
OPEN PROJECTS
- A photo is needed for:
- Ashley Brooks, Miss Gay Indianapolis America 1994
- Misty McCrea, Miss Gay Indianapolis America 1999
- Tandy Ross, Miss Gay Indianapolis America 2000
