Miss Gay Metropolitan America is a prelim to Miss Gay Ohio America.
Miss Gay Metropolitan America Titleholders
Michelle Stevens 
Ashley West 
Hellin Bedd 
Symphony Alexander-Love 
Brionna Brooks 
Aaliyah Milian 
Rushena Fontaine 
Britney Blaire 
Rosario Garcia 
Kiley Dash-West – Photo by Neal Raffensberger 
Cherry Poppins 
Ava Aurora Foxx – Photo by Laura Dark Photography
Miss Gay Metropolitan America Titleholders
- 2003 – Michelle Stevens
- 2007 – Ashley West
- 2008 – Hellin Bedd
- 2009 – Symphony Alexander-Love
- 2010 – Brionna Brooks
- 2011 – Aaliyah Milian
- 2012 – Rushena Fontaine
- 2013 – Britney Blaire
- 2014 – Rosario Garcia
- 2016 – Kiley Dash-West
- 2017 – Cherry Poppins
- 2019 – Ava Aurora Foxx
Miss Gay Metropolitan America History
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2019
- Winner – Ava Aurora Foxx
- 1st Alternate – Sabrina Caprice Heartt
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2018
No pageant held.
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2017
- Winner – Cherry Poppins
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2016
- Winner – Kiley Dash-West
- 1st Alternate – Mercedes Denishayae Marie Taylor
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2015
No pageant held
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2014
- Winner – Rosario Garcia
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2013
- Winner – Britney Blaire
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2012
- Winner – Rushena Fontaine
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2011
- Winner – Aaliyah Milian
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2010
- Winner – Brionna Brooks
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2009
- Winner – Symphony Alexander-Love
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2008
- Winner – Hellin Bedd
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2007
- Winner – Ashley West
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2004 – 2006
No pageant held
Miss Gay Metropolitan America 2003
- Winner – Michelle Stevens
