Miss Gay Evansville became a direct prelim to Miss Gay Indiana in 2008. Prior to this, it was a city pageant and was a prelim to Miss Gay Indiana America through 2005 when the state pageant separated itself from the Miss Gay America organization.
Miss Gay Evansville America Titleholders
- 2001 – Athena Michaels
- 2003 – LaShae Roberts
- 2004 – Jasmine Roberts
Miss Gay Evansville Titleholders
- 2008 – Veronica Cruise
- 2009 – Dakota Carmichael ***
- 2010 – Annastacia DeMoore
- 2011 – Krystal Barbie Dicanter
- 2012 – Briana Michaels
- 2013 – Mysti Dawn
- 2014 – Mysti Dawn and Dakota Carmichael
- 2015 – Myesha Stratton
- 2016 – Bendovah Plenti
- 2017 – Anita Cath
- 2019 – Dixxxie Licious
*** In Loving Memory
Miss Gay Evansville History
NOTES:
- There was a contest held in 2018 but the winner was removed.
