Through 2005, this pageant was a prelim to Mr. Gay All-American (later named Mr. Gay America) and was known as Mr. Gay Indiana All-American.
After 2005, the pageant separated itself from the Mr. Gay All-America organization and is known as Mr. Gay Indiana. The system honors all of the previous Mr. Gay Indiana All-American winners as formers.
In 2018, longtime promoter Cleo Brasher was awarded the Life Time Achievement Award and proclaimed to be the emeritus to the system.
Mr. Gay Indiana America Titleholders
Mr. Gay Indiana America Titleholders
- 1987 – Brad Bemis
- 1993 – James Randall
- 1996 – Richard Greer ***
- 2000 – Patrick King
- 2001 – Kole Michaels
***In Loving Memory
Mr. Gay Indiana Titleholders
Mr. Gay Indiana Titleholders
- 2010 – Xavier Cruz
- 2011 – Parker Ale
- 2012 – Elite St. James
- 2013 – Monroe DeMoore
- 2014 – Apollo Summers
- 2015 – Tailor Made
- 2016 – Kalos Techne
- 2017 – Lorenzo Luckardo
- 2018 – Lil D’Licious
- 2019 – The Prince of Shock
- 2022 – AiJaye Finessé
Prelims to Mr. Gay Indiana
Mr. Gay Indiana America / Mr. Gay Indiana History
Mr. Gay Indiana 2022
- Winner – AiJaye Finessé
Mr. Gay Indiana 2020 – 2021
Need to research years.
Mr. Gay Indiana 2019
- Winner – The Prince of Shock
- 1st Alternate – Coree Sheers
Mr. Gay Indiana 2018
- Winner – Lil D’Licious
Mr. Gay Indiana 2017
- Winner – Lorenzo Luckardo
- 1st Alternate –
- 2nd Alternate – Titanium Steele Yo Weave
Mr. Gay Indiana 2016
- Winner – Kalos Techne
Other Awards:
- Mr. Personality – Kris King Hall
Mr. Gay Indiana 2015
- Winner – Tailor Made
Mr. Gay Indiana 2014
- Winner – Apollo Summers
Mr. Gay Indiana 2013
- Winner – Monroe DeMoore
Mr. Gay Indiana 2012
- Winner – Elite St. James
Mr. Gay Indiana 2011
Needs researched
Mr. Gay Indiana 2010
- Winner – Xavier Cruz
Mr. Gay Indiana 2002 – 2009
Needs researched
Mr. Gay Indiana All-American 2001
- Winner – Kole Michaels
Mr. Gay Indiana All-American 2000
- Winner – Patrick King
Mr. Gay Indiana All-American 1996
- Winner – Richard Greer
Mr. Gay Indiana All-American 1987
- Winner – Brad Bemis
