
Miss Gay Akron is a prelim to Miss Gay Ohio America.
Titleholders to Miss Gay Akron America
Darah Landon Desarae Duvoe Erica Martinez Ashley West Kelley Cheval Erica Martinez KiArra Cartie Fontaine Amber Marie Martini Glazz Jazmyn James Symphony Alexander-Love – Miss Gay Ohio America 2009 KeYanna Unique Diamond Katrina St. Clair Elegance Black Lourdes Natasha Styles Rachel Torrez-Kolbe Natasha Gibson Joy Montiero Desiree Monroe Sasha Bonet Valerie Valentino – Photo by Todd Simpson Dymondé Lorez St. Clair Alejandra J-Love
Miss Gay Akron America Titleholders
- 1993 – Darah Landon
- 1994 – Desarae Duvoe
- 1995 – Erica Martinez
- 1996 – Ashley West
- 1998 – Kelley Cheval
- 2000 – Erica Martinez
- 2002 – KiArra Cartier Fontaine *
- 2003 – Amber Marie
- 2004 – Martini Glazz
- 2005 – Jazmyn James
- 2006 – Symphony Alexander-Love
- 2006/2007 – KeYanna Unique Diamond
- 2007 – Katrina St. Clair
- 2008 – Elegance Black Lourdes
- 2009 – Natasha Sytles
- 2010 – Rachel Torrez-Kolbe
- 2013 – Natasha Gibson
- 2015 – Joy Montiero
- 2016 – Desiree Monroe Crumble
- 2017 – Sasha Bonet
- 2018 – Valerie Valentino
- 2019-2020 – Dymondé Lorez St. Clair
- 2021 – Alejandra J-Love
*In Loving Memory
Miss Gay Akron America History
Miss Gay Akron America 2021
- Winner – Alejandra J-Love
- 1st Alternate – Maelstrom West
Miss Gay Akron America 2020
No pageant held due to Covid-19 pandemic.
Miss Gay Akron America 2019
- Winner – Dymondé Lorez St. Clair
Miss Gay Akron America 2018
- Winner – Valerie Valentino
- 1st Alternate – Dymondé Lorez St. Clair

Miss Gay Akron America 2017
- Winner – Sasha Bonet

Miss Gay Akron America 2016
- Winner – Desiree Monroe Crumble

Miss Gay Akron America 2015
Contestants: Joy Montiero, Kaleigha Diamond and Katora Brandy
- Winner: Joy Montiero
- 1st Alternate: Kaleigha Diamond
- 2nd Alternate: Katora Brandy
Category Awards:
- Presentation (non-judged): Kaleigha Diamond
- Male Interview: Joy Montiero
- Solo Talent: Joy Montiero
- Evening Gown: Kaleigha Diamond
- On Stage Question & Answer: Joy Montiero
- Talent: Kaleigha Diamond

Miss Gay Akron America 2010
- Winner – Rachel Torrez-Kolbe
*Below show ad was made with wrong years. This was for the Miss Gay Akron America 2010 pageant and was honoring Natasha Styles Miss Gay Akron America 2009.
