Miss Gay Cincinnati America is a prelim to Miss Gay Ohio America.
Miss Gay Cincinnati America Titleholders
Miss Gay Cincinnati America Titleholders
- 1993 – Jennifer Hart
- 1994 – Montana Gray
- 1995 – Patricia Holt
- 1996 – Erica Rae O’Hara
- 1998 – Racine Alexander
- 1999 – Tracey Allen
- 2002 – Cierra Nicole
- 2003 – Lady Jetta
- 2004 – Cece Devine
- 2006 – Bella Dolce ***
- 2007 – Jessica Dimon
- 2009 – Holly Berry
- 2011 – Mahoganay Halsten Soule
- 2013 – Destiny Fayte ***
- 2014 – Misty Phoenix St. James
- 2015 – Amanda Sue
- 2016 – Trinity Monroe
***In Loving Memory
Miss Gay Cincinnati America History
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1993
- Winner – Jennifer Hart
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1994
- Winner – Montana Gray
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1995
- Winner – Patricia Holt
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1996
- Winner – Erica Rae O’Hara
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1997
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1998
- Winner – Racine Alexander
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 1999
- Winner – Tracey Allen
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2000 – 2001
- No pageant held
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2002
- Winner – Cierra Nicole
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2003
- Winner – Lady Jetta
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2004
- Winner – Cece Devine
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2005
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2006
- Winner – Bella Dolce
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2007
- Winner – Jessica Dimon
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2008
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2009
- Winner – Holly Berry
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2010
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2011
- Winner – Mahoganay Halsten Soule
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2012
- No pageant held.
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2013
- Winner – Destiny Fayte
- 1st Alternate – Tina Hightower
- ARCHIVE: Miss Gay Cincinnati America | The Cabaret (Cincinnati, Ohio) | 6/13/2013
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2014
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2015
- Winner – Amanda Sue
- Miss Gay Cincinnati America 2016
- Winner – Trinity Monroe
- 1st Alternate – Ria Richards
