Miss Gay Muncie, now a independent city title, had previously been a prelim to both Miss Gay Indiana (starting in 2008) and Miss Gay Indiana America (through 2005).
Ginger La’Vie 
Brandi Ice 
Joy Fairbanks 
India Black 
Caress 
Erica King 
Roxy Russell 
Amanda Nicole 
In Loving Memory of Rose Petal 
Imon 
Jazmyn Taylor 
Angela Stone 
Heaven Sinclair 
Chelsea Nicole Parker 
Brooklyn Starr 
Sasha Michaels 
Ana Crusis 
Heather Bea – Photo by Juan Rivera 
Holly Luyah 
Courtney Kelly 
Patience Eau Claire 
Leana Myers 
Mahogany Charlotte 
Scarlett Kelly
Miss Gay Muncie and Miss Gay Muncie America Titleholders
- 1995 – Ginger La’Vie
- 1996 – Brandi Ice
- 1997 – Joy Fairbanks
- 1998 – India Black
- 1999 – Caress
- 2000 – Erica King
- 2001 – Roxy Russell
- 2002 – Amanda Nicole ***
- 2003 – Rose Petal ***
- 2004 – Imon
- 2005 – Jazmyn Taylor
- 2006 – Angela Stone
- 2007 – Heaven Sinclair
- 2008 – Chelsea Nicole Parker
- 2009 – Brooklyn Starr
- 2010 – Sasha Michaels
- 2011 – Ana Crusis
- 2012 – Heather Bea
- 2013 – 2014 – Holly Luyah
- 2015 – Courtney Kelly
- 2016 – Patience Eau Claire
- 2017 – Leana Myers
- 2018 – Mahogany Charlotte
- 2019 – Scarlett Kelly
*** In Loving Memory
Miss Gay Muncie ane Miss Gay Muncie America History
Miss Gay Muncie 2019
- Winner – Scarlett Kelly
Miss Gay Muncie 2018
- Winner – Sasha Leigh Chambers
Sasha Leigh Chambers won the title but moved out of the area and the title went to Mahogany Charlotte.
Miss Gay Muncie 2017
- Winner – Leana Myers
Miss Gay Muncie 2016
- Winner – Patience Eau Claire
Miss Gay Muncie 2015
- Winner – Courtney Kelly
- 1st Alternate – Juwanna DeMoore
Miss Gay Muncie 2014
No pageant held.
Miss Gay Muncie 2013
- Winner – Holly Luyah
Miss Gay Muncie 2012
- Winner – Heather Bea
Miss Gay Muncie 2011
- Winner – Anna Crusis
Miss Gay Muncie 2010
- Winner – Sasha Michaels
Miss Gay Muncie 2009
- Winner – Brooklyn Starr
Miss Gay Muncie 2008
- Winner – Chelsea Nicole Parker
Miss Gay Muncie 2007
- Winner – Heaven Sinclair
Miss Gay Muncie 2006
- Winner – Angela Stone
Miss Gay Muncie America 2005
- Winner – Jazmyn Taylor
Miss Gay Muncie America 2004
- Winner – Imon
Miss Gay Muncie America 2003
- Winner – Rose Petal
Miss Gay Muncie America 2002
- Winner – Amanda Nicole
Miss Gay Muncie America 2001
- Winner – Roxy Russell
Miss Gay Muncie America 2000
- Winner – Erica King
- 1st Alternate – Rose Petal
Miss Gay Muncie America 1999
- Winner – Caress
Miss Gay Muncie America 1998
- Winner – India Black
Miss Gay Muncie America 1997
- Winner – Joy Fairbanks
Miss Gay Muncie America 1996
- Winner – Brandi Ice
Miss Gay Muncie America 1995
- Winner – Ginger La’Vie
